When you’re updating your house during a home remodeling project, one big question always pops up: should you refinish your kitchen cabinets or go ahead and replace them? Cabinets take up a lot of space and are one of the first things people notice when they walk into your kitchen. So the choice really matters—especially if you’re trying to stick to a budget.
In this article, we’ll break it down in simple terms. You’ll learn the key differences between refinishing and replacing, how much each costs, and which one makes more sense for your home. Whether you’re doing a full kitchen makeover or just trying to freshen up the space, this will help you decide.
What’s the Difference Between Refinishing and Replacing Cabinets?
Let’s keep this simple.
Refinishing means you’re keeping your current cabinets but giving them a new look. That could mean sanding them down and painting or staining them. You’re not changing the shape or size just updating the outside.
Replacing, on the other hand, means you’re taking out your old cabinets and installing brand-new ones. You get a fresh start with new styles, new colors, and even a new layout if you want.
Which Option Is Cheaper?
If we’re talking money, refinishing is usually way easier on the wallet. Most homeowners spend anywhere from $1,500 to $5,000 to refinish cabinets. It depends on how big your kitchen is and the type of finish you want.
Now if you’re thinking about replacing them? Be ready to spend more anywhere from $6,000 to over $20,000. Especially if you want custom cabinets or a whole new kitchen setup.
So, if budget is your main concern during home remodeling, refinishing is the more affordable option.
When Does Refinishing Make Sense?
Refinishing is a smart move when:
- Your cabinets are in good shape—no cracks, water damage, or broken pieces
- You just want a fresh, modern look without changing the whole layout
- You’re working with a tight budget
- You want the job done quickly and with less mess
In other words, if your cabinets just look old but still work fine, refinishing can save you time and cash.
When Should You Replace Cabinets Instead?
Sometimes, refinishing just won’t cut it. You might want to replace your cabinets if:
- They’re damaged, warped, or falling apart
- You need more storage space
- You’re changing the kitchen’s layout completely
- You want soft-close drawers, hidden shelves, or newer features
Replacing makes more sense during full home remodeling projects, especially when you’re aiming to upgrade your whole kitchen from top to bottom.
What About Home Value?
Now let’s talk about getting the most for your money.
Refinishing can definitely make your kitchen look better, but it won’t increase your home’s value as much as full replacement.
Replacing cabinets, on the other hand, is more of an investment. It can help you sell your house faster and even raise the price. Buyers love new kitchens. So if you’re planning to sell in the near future, new cabinets might be the better move.
How Long Will It Take?
Here’s what you can expect:
Refinishing usually takes about 3 to 5 days. It’s quick and doesn’t involve tearing things apart.
Replacing can take 2 to 4 weeks, especially if you’re ordering custom cabinets. It also might require other work like plumbing or electrical changes.
If you’re doing home remodeling while still living in the house, time can be a big factor.
What Lasts Longer?
New cabinets almost always last longer. They’re made with newer materials, better hardware, and modern features. They’re easier to clean too.
Refinished cabinets look nice, but over time, the paint or stain may chip or fade—especially in busy kitchens. With proper care, they can still last a good number of years, just not as long as brand-new ones.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can I refinish my cabinets by myself?
Yes, if you’re handy and patient, you can refinish your own cabinets. But if you want a smooth and professional look, it’s a good idea to hire someone—especially during a bigger home remodeling job.
2. What kind of paint or stain lasts the longest?
Oil-based paints and good-quality stains usually hold up better over time. Adding a protective coat helps make them last even longer.
3. How do I know if my cabinets are too old to refinish?
If the wood is cracking, warped, or falling apart, refinishing won’t help much. In that case, replacing it is your best bet.
4. Will new cabinets raise the value of my home?
Yes. In many cases, updated kitchens help sell homes faster and for more money. New cabinets can definitely add value during a home remodeling upgrade.
5. How do I decide between refinishing and replacing?
It really depends on your budget, the shape of your current cabinets, and your long-term goals. If you want a quick facelift, refinish. If you’re ready for a full transformation, replace.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between refinishing and replacing cabinets is a big step in any home remodeling project. The good news? Both options can make a big difference in how your kitchen looks and feels.
If you’re on a budget and your cabinets are still in good shape, refinishing is probably all you need. But if you’re ready for a full upgrade and want something fresh and custom, replacing may be the better choice.
Still unsure? Talk to a local home remodeling expert—they’ll help you weigh your options and make the best call for your space.
